Skip to content
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
57 changes: 57 additions & 0 deletions docs/research/standalone-history-scalar-ceiling/EVIDENCE-INDEX.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
# Written-proof evidence and original-label remap

The twelve payloads below are unchanged LOCAL proof, acceptance, review and conditional-source snapshots. [SOURCE-MANIFEST.json](SOURCE-MANIFEST.json) records exact hashes, byte lengths and original labels. They are not registered executable inputs or claims that private source programs have been bundled or newly validated. The four new navigation/provenance documents are README, this index, the manifest and handoff.

## Current written-review status

| Result | Exact proof | Additive acceptance | Independent AI static review |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Fixed-word central Laurent extension | [Lemma](proofs/central-lemma-v1.md), e4ead15d… | [Report](acceptance/central-report.md), 7508cb57…; [decision](acceptance/central-decision.json) | [Report](reviews/central-report.md), 6438f2df…; [decision](reviews/central-decision.json), 5a53ed0e… |
| Eventual pointwise extension | [Lemma](proofs/pointwise-lemma-v1.md), ac2a5a7c… | [Report](acceptance/pointwise-report.md), c4451f41…; [decision](acceptance/pointwise-decision.json), 9c6b9514… | [Report](reviews/pointwise-report.md), c49f6c25…; [decision](reviews/pointwise-decision.json), 1177ef15… |

The original PROPOSED headings and old pending-review statements in the exact lemmas remain historical. Acceptance is additive and the independent decisions require no mathematical correction. The pointwise guard is each f≥2p−1 for a fixed finite projective ordinary family; it is not a practical-width result. Both variants exclude free correlated nonordinary paid history initially.

## Direct predecessor and the added scope

The direct public predecessor is [#5425's standalone ordinary-module history argument](https://github.com/Clear1nsight/integer-mult-bounds/tree/00005c8c5e81c7f27b5769f9309ff88758e26f51/research/fanout-optimality-support), at head `00005c8c5e81c7f27b5769f9309ff88758e26f51`. Its cached body declares module-proof SHA256 `cfa9f3df855f96a3e73bcb8042a750a3aa41d18ec098d6a34268370f3e84d782` and explicitly allows feedback/overwrites with ordinary initial history, fixed capacity and a finite columnwise ordinary group. The monitor supplied the immutable package-tree locator and declared proof hash; no new predecessor proof fetch or scientific replay is claimed here.

This note extends that principle to fixed central c·2^(n f) normalizers and to arbitrary exterior c(f) with nonuniform finite words and N(f) at each f≥2p−1. Its conditional 120-coordinate nomination is separate from the predecessor's 112-output specialization. It is an extension/application of an existing history argument, not a new general history principle.

## Source nomination and link remap

The [source report](source/standalone-local-report.md), 6dc97b31…, supplies the ordered T=A Jbar A^-1 nomination, 120 distinct input coordinates, nonmonomial support and surjectivity arguments, and the conditional signed-profile inequality. The [conversion obligation](source/conversion-obligation.md), 70230e2b…, makes the exact standalone resource contract explicit. These documents do not make this note a physical BC implementation or admitted supplier.

The following original labels inside frozen appendices resolve to the copied artifacts here. A reference to a source program or another audit not listed below remains an inherited source premise, not a new public dependency or execution claim.

| Original LOCAL label suffix | Public copy |
| --- | --- |
| `coded-canonical-conversion-ceiling-20261024/REPORT.md` | [Source report](source/standalone-local-report.md) |
| `CONVERSION-OBLIGATION.md` | [Conversion obligation](source/conversion-obligation.md) |
| `central-scalar-extension/PROPOSED-LEMMA-v1.md` | [Central proof](proofs/central-lemma-v1.md) |
| `central-scalar-extension/REPORT.md` / `DECISION.json` | [Acceptance](acceptance/central-report.md) / [decision](acceptance/central-decision.json) |
| `central-scalar-independent/REPORT.md` / `DECISION.json` | [Review](reviews/central-report.md) / [decision](reviews/central-decision.json) |
| `pointwise-scalar-extension/PROPOSED-LEMMA-v1.md` | [Pointwise proof](proofs/pointwise-lemma-v1.md) |
| `pointwise-scalar-extension/REPORT.md` / `DECISION.json` | [Acceptance](acceptance/pointwise-report.md) / [decision](acceptance/pointwise-decision.json) |
| `pointwise-scalar-independent/REPORT.md` / `DECISION.json` | [Review](reviews/pointwise-report.md) / [decision](reviews/pointwise-decision.json) |

No raw native word, provider kernel, helper census, source scan, scientific checker or constructor is imported. Original source-path labels and old publication-status statements are preserved as evidence history. The top-level narrative links to the copies above rather than to workspace paths.

## Primary-reference attribution

Anthony Chefles, *Unambiguous Discrimination Between Linearly Dependent States With Multiple Copies*, Physical Review A 64, 062305 (2001), [DOI](https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.64.062305), [inspected manuscript version](https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0105016v3). The sole literature worker's LOCAL fit note is SHA256 `bf92eaf26ae87303e6f1f8a893a33db48009b93b5c3ec269b2d426f2c2ad3562`; its retained inspected manuscript hash is `38f5efd58c5c4f902e40cfb6283c804650bf1d5ebd2678a89ffe7710e44ecdb9`. This note neither repeats that paper review nor claims the classical tensor observation as new.

Peter Kropholler and Karl Lorensen, *Group-graded rings satisfying the strong rank condition*, Journal of Algebra 539 (2019), 326–338, [DOI](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jalgebra.2019.08.014), [inspected manuscript version](https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.10001v2). The sole literature worker's LOCAL fit note is `170e3c9923f0c9b7543f7775b00aeda953691012d82e84ecea43ed861827e5fb`; its inspected manuscript hash is `9ed6eaa9ed0a459da9411dc4739152ff93d72f27d0d38c0b70f109e168df51f1`. The central proof is self-contained; the published theorem provides corroboration.

Only short factual attribution, URLs and hashes are retained here. No third-party paper PDF/text, full bibliography or raw agent/chat coordination log is included.

## Scope of inspection and overlap

The retained reports record written reasoning, source-text inspection and byte hashes. No native, phase, rank, operator, calibration, numerical-power, price, Lean or other proof engine was run for this documentation note. Independent AI static review is separate from human review, formal verification, hosted tooling checks and supplier admission.

The sole monitor's checkpoint 1347 was captured at 2026-10-24 13:47:44 UTC, with current all-author/all-state PR metadata coverage through 13:33:40 UTC and selective body/source review. At exact cached [PR5436 head](https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/commit/4c31fd7d4eee61ff9fd59533549a67ef1a25b449) `4c31fd7d4eee61ff9fd59533549a67ef1a25b449`, zxv's moving-support statement and four-control 2705-source corollary supplied the prompt. Their proof, count, calibration and execution claims are not independently adopted here. This bounded overlap context is not universal novelty coverage.

The supplied prepublication receipt is SHA256 `3f68e99596c99eb0597baaedcc69d40b11748153f2a31df3c9a2eaf75b74ca48`, recorded at 2026-10-24 16:52:00 UTC with current metadata/body coverage through 16:50:42 UTC and a subsequent static locator addendum. It covers 100 recent all-state records, reports no changed nearby exact-scope claim in that incremental pass, and leaves main/guidance/selected unchanged. It does not exhaust Discussion history or unpublished work. The cached #5425 body is `b84a70a51002eeb5aa54c74e1e78865a79f276dee6d0defb852a68d20d0cd1ab`.

Adjacent exact heads are [#5441](https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/commit/11fedb46fa199283f78282187c10aea432d8b0bb), for fixed physical transfer-table endpoint/cut bounds, and [#5442](https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/commit/19e8f0452c09cbfe99511ea697fa239c1f457314), for a finite-group all-width lifting lemma and a separately claimed complete-body certificate. The latter claim is [challenged by review comment 6385984727](https://github.com/CrocSwap/integer-mult-bounds/pull/5442#issuecomment-6385984727). This note adopts neither that executable certificate nor its body-closure claim; neither is a dependency of the conditional LOCAL nomination. A finite-width affine diagnostic for a different family supplies no replacement for this note's ordinary-group/target-coset separation. No such calibration is imported or executed here.

The [handoff](HANDOFF.md) distinguishes the current local assembly from any later commit, public readback or hosted CI result.
22 changes: 22 additions & 0 deletions docs/research/standalone-history-scalar-ceiling/HANDOFF.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
HANDOFF

Research discussion / PR / artifact:
[Standalone paid-return histories with scalar extensions](README.md), with the [immutable proof/review snapshot](https://github.com/Clear1nsight/integer-mult-bounds/blob/56c52a79f7663bc59ad3a5013c242a113039a701/docs/research/standalone-history-scalar-ceiling/README.md). The upstream PR is the canonical investigation thread for this documentation contribution. The note is unregistered written mathematics with independent AI static reviews, not an executable research capsule.

Exact commit:
Proof/review snapshot: 56c52a79f7663bc59ad3a5013c242a113039a701; authenticated canonical base: 32890bc5de034ab8fc93ac88ead7279a6a416d04. A later metadata-only commit pins this handoff; the upstream PR and public handoff identify its publication head separately. The twelve original proof/review/source payloads retain their exact LOCAL byte hashes in [SOURCE-MANIFEST.json](SOURCE-MANIFEST.json); they are not fabricated canonical source roots. The canonical CI-navigation repair is already present and has no duplicate delta here.

What is established:
The ordinary-module paid-history principle is retained from [#5425 at exact head 00005c8c…](https://github.com/Clear1nsight/integer-mult-bounds/tree/00005c8c5e81c7f27b5769f9309ff88758e26f51/research/fanout-optimality-support), including feedback/overwrites, ordinary initial span and fixed capacity. This note adds the fixed-word central c·2^(n f) variant at all positive widths or a consecutive infinite tail, and the eventual pointwise arbitrary-c(f) variant with nonuniform finite words and N(f), only at each f≥2p−1 for one fixed finite ordinary G and geometry. Both yield at least q actual new returns for the stated q independent invertible target coordinates. No new history principle or transfer of the predecessor's 112-output application is claimed. The pointwise threshold may be astronomical. Independent AI reviews accept the exact scalar-extension proofs without a required correction; acceptance reports preserve the original PROPOSED headings. The q=120 source example remains a conditional LOCAL mathematical nomination, with its ordered target, nonmonomial and independent-input arguments copied for inspection. The supplied sole-monitor refresh covers current PR metadata/body records through 2026-10-24 16:50:42 UTC, bounded rather than exhaustive; main/guidance/selected are unchanged.

What remains uncertain:
The written proofs and documentation scope have separate independent AI static reviews. Independent human or formal-kernel review and a source-specific application remain open. Public readback and hosted tooling status are recorded on the upstream PR; neither supplies physical or scientific admission. The supplied prepublication refresh does not approve future byte changes. Neither theorem establishes an additional paid-call charge at an actual parent cut with cached/native/paid observations. No practical-width application, physical BC ABI/implementation, admitted supplier, new productive target, uniform recursive cost/precision/stock contract or new kappa follows. Adjacent #5441 concerns transfer endpoints/cut dimensions; #5442's claimed complete-body closure is challenged and is not a dependency here. No small-width affine corollary replaces this note's large fixed ordinary-group/target-coset separation. A shallow/shared base checkout does not prove full source history or corpus availability. The copied source premises are not freshly replayed.

Smallest useful next task:
The next distinct research question is the actual cut's versioned available-history module and target containment, including ownership, retention and opportunity costs. That question remains outside this note and with its owner. A source-specific smaller width threshold also needs a separate justified argument.

Reproduction command and expected runtime:
None for a scientific replay. Read the [two proofs and their independent reviews](EVIDENCE-INDEX.md). There is no VERIFY.json, verifier, numerical RESULT or registered command. Assembly checks are limited to copied-byte hashes, local navigation and Git diff/metadata; their results cannot certify the theorem or a supplier. No paper PDF/text, raw agent/chat log, peer-owned helper census or constructor is included.

Predecessor credit:
The #5425 finite ordinary-module proof/reviewer directly, including its feedback/overwrites argument; Anthony Chefles for classical tensor/projective independence; Peter Kropholler and Karl Lorensen and their credited strong-rank predecessors; zxv for the #5436 support-width prompt; scalar/source authors, root's localization and paid-history application question, independent reviewers and sole literature worker; and the BC/native/Clifford/product/compiler/precision/analytic lineage. Preserve Ali Romman, Dillon Amburgey/dillona, Cao Yifan, Cinna Davis, zxv, Dugongue, Jacob Alan Sussman, Chris R/Clear1nsight and the retained notices. Substantial OpenAI Codex assistance. No independent human or formal-kernel verification is claimed.
Loading