Skip to content

Bump bundled Trivy from 0.58.1 to a measured current release #372

Closed

Description

@LarsLaskowski

The Dockerfile pins aquasec/trivy:0.58.1 (src/DockerUpdateGuard/Dockerfile, line 4). The protection from #367 (-- before the Trivy scan target, decision record 0015) was measured on Trivy v0.76.1, because the v0.58.1 release archive answers HTTP 404.

Move the pin to v0.76.1, or the release current at the time, and check that the pinned image can still be pulled. Then re-run the #367 cases against the bundled binary with TRIVY_SERVER pointing at an unreachable server:

  • no --, target --config=x.y/z:latest: read as an option (config file loading error);
  • -- followed by each of --config=x.y/z:latest, --input=/tmp/x.tar:latest and -a/b:latest: treated as an image name, non-zero exit, no file read;
  • -- library/alpine:3.20: normal scan path.

This closes row 12 of the #367 plan. It touches Docker/build configuration, so it is a security area under AGENTS.md.

Activity

  1. LarsLaskowski commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @LarsLaskowski
    OwnerAuthor

    Squad working record

    plan.md (summary, tier standard)

    Full plan at the last commit that contains it: https://github.com/LarsLaskowski/DockerUpdateGuard/blob/8ee534efe96b433635340a95bfd9870e937feb6b/specs/issue-372/plan.md

    • Tier: standard; security areas touched: container image and runtime user, external process execution, Docker/build configuration, dependency (Trivy CLI and server image), runtime environment.
    • Change: Dockerfile TRIVY_IMAGE moves to the digest of the v0.76.1 image index (aquasec/trivy@sha256:790fd66d1697395d8693d1acaa1ea702406a20f109b6fc7bac8db623eca6c06c); both compose Trivy servers move to aquasec/trivy:0.76.1; the image sets TRIVY_SKIP_VERSION_CHECK=true and TRIVY_DISABLE_TELEMETRY=true; area documents and records 0015, 0005 and new 0016 updated.
    • Criteria: AC1 pin and pull, AC2 binary, AC3 the Trivy scan target can begin with a dash #367 cases against the bundled binary, AC4 compose/server flags, AC5 no remaining 0.58.1 outside history, AC6 no call to check.trivy.dev (control run shows it, final run does not).
    • Decisions: Security's plan review found that v0.76.1 sends an update check with a host identifier to check.trivy.dev on every scan; resolved by the two image environment variables (record 0016). Challenge skipped: no production code.
    • Deviations from the plan: (1) the plan text still carries the early wording "contacts only the Trivy server and the registries"; the review corrected it in the shipped documents, since Trivy also contacts the Docker Engine socket first. (2) AC1 asked for tag plus digest on the Dockerfile default; SonarCloud rule docker:S8431 forbids both, so the default is digest-only with the version in a comment (same bytes).
    log.md
    Date Step Member Result
    2026-10-29 20:39 1 Intake Orchestrator Issue 372 read: bug/chore, Trivy bump, security area (Docker config); branch fix-issue-372-bump-trivy
    2026-10-29 20:44 2 Plan Lead plan.md written, tier standard, security areas touched; challenge skipped: no options; plan-check PASS (opus/medium · 83,078 tokens · 25 tool uses · 292 s)
    2026-10-29 20:47 3 Plan security review Security CHANGES_REQUIRED: B1 Trivy 0.76.1 phones home (check.trivy.dev) on every scan; needs suppression + pinning criterion; N1 measurement also calls home (opus/medium · 56,081 tokens · 16 tool uses · 137 s)
    2026-10-29 20:50 3 Plan revise Lead Revised for B1: option a (ENV TRIVY_SKIP_VERSION_CHECK/TRIVY_DISABLE_TELEMETRY in Dockerfile), AC6 pin, record 0016 Proposed; plan-check PASS (opus/medium · 63,020 tokens · 13 tool uses · 153 s)
    2026-10-29 20:52 3 Plan security review Security Confirmation of revision: APPROVED; B1/N1 resolved; NB1, NB2 appended as Security notes (opus/medium · 63,050 tokens · 14 tool uses · 146 s)
    2026-10-29 20:52 4-5 Skeleton, tests first Orchestrator skipped: plan declares no production or test code (Verification without tests)
    2026-10-29 20:57 6 Implement Dev Dockerfile pin+digest, 2 skip ENVs, compose files, area docs; AC1-AC6 measured and passed (registry via mirror.gcr.io; docker.io 429) (sonnet/medium · 100,556 tokens · 24 tool uses · 253 s)
    2026-10-29 20:58 6 Records Lead Edited records 0015 and 0005 after measurements; 0016 stays Proposed until approval (opus/medium · 40,579 tokens · 6 tool uses · 32 s)
    2026-10-29 20:58 7 Code check Orchestrator no code changed: hadolint, scope-check, decision-check, plan-check PASS
    2026-10-29 21:00 7 Sonar gate Orchestrator NOT CHECKED: analysis uploaded, results API 403 'not allowed to access data from non main branches'; no code in change; re-check in step 11 via PR
    2026-10-29 21:02 8 Review round 1 Reviewer BLOCKING 1: 'contacts only the Trivy server and the registries' false (Docker socket is contacted first); verbatim fix in 4 places; non-blocking 0 (opus/medium · 52,026 tokens · 10 tool uses · 94 s)
    2026-10-29 21:03 8 Fix round 1 Dev Fixed docker-socket claim in vulnerabilities.md, hosting.md, Dockerfile comment (sonnet/medium · 65,557 tokens · 4 tool uses · 19 s)
    2026-10-29 21:03 8 Fix round 1 Lead Fixed claim in record 0016 (opus/medium · 30,001 tokens · 5 tool uses · 16 s)
    2026-10-29 21:03 8 Review round 2 (delta) Reviewer APPROVE: blocking finding resolved, no stale claim left (opus/medium · 9,205 tokens · 3 tool uses · 19 s · continued)
    2026-10-29 21:03 9 PR approval Orchestrator approved by checklist: review clean on head, gates pass, main unmoved, area docs in diff; record 0016 set to Accepted
    2026-10-29 21:04 10 Pull request Orchestrator Working record commented on #372; PR #376 opened as draft; subscribed
    2026-10-29 21:04 12 Wrap-up Orchestrator no lessons
    2026-10-29 21:08 11 Sonar fix Dev docker:S8431: Trivy image pinned by digest only, hosting.md (sonnet/medium · 66,052 tokens · 6 tool uses · 24 s)
    2026-10-29 21:08 11 Sonar fix Lead record 0015 wording: pinned by digest (opus/medium · 30,200 tokens · 10 tool uses · 36 s)
    2026-10-29 21:09 11 Review delta Reviewer APPROVE: digest unchanged, no stale claim; AC1 tag+digest dropped for Sonar S8431 (opus/medium · 6,061 tokens · 3 tool uses · 19 s · continued)
    2026-10-29 21:13 11 Re-approval Orchestrator approved by checklist: CI and Sonar quality gate green on dbb4f20, delta review clean, main unmoved; PR marked ready

    Squad run metrics

    Member Model/effort Launches Tokens Tool uses Seconds
    Dev sonnet/medium 3 232,165 34 296
    Lead opus/medium 5 246,878 59 529
    Reviewer opus/medium 3 (2 continued) 61,231 15 125
    Security opus/medium 2 119,131 30 283
    Total 13 (2 continued) 659,405 138 1233
    Member Wall time (s) Not covered by launches (s) Gate runs
    Orchestrator 2,040 885 2
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions