You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Evaluate generic ellipse and tangent path-repeat geometry #110
MinePilot issue #73 stress-tested three reusable families in an isolated worktree: a CircleRing/RadialRepeat circular arena control, a manually approximated elliptical shell, and a three-level elliptical arcade using ArcadeRun plus cap arcs. The full local report is in i365dev/MinePilot issue #73 worktree under docs/ISSUE_73_CURVED_RADIAL_STRESS_TEST.md.
Findings
CircleRing is sufficient for a basic circular shell, but endpoint samples can trigger disconnected/floating support diagnostics.
The elliptical shell requires four partial CircleRing arcs with separate centers/radii plus hand-authored tangent walls; it is visibly faceted and brittle to repair.
The multi-level arcade can use ArcadeRun on straight tangent sides, but bays cannot follow an oval path or rotate to local tangent orientation. Cap arcs and broad platforms obscure the repeated bays.
Both the shell and arcade families independently reproduce the same generic gap: no bounded ellipse/curve path and no path-based tangent-oriented repeat. This is not a request for a Colosseum-specific primitive.
Proposed evaluation
Please evaluate a small orthogonal extension, in sequence:
An EllipseRing or bounded CurvePath that deterministically expands to existing voxel nodes.
A PathRepeat primitive/authoring helper for assemblies with explicit, quantized rotation semantics.
Endpoint support diagnostics and safe prototype anchoring for CircleRing + RadialRepeat.
Require fixtures for both an elliptical shell and a multi-level curved arcade before accepting an implementation. Keep true freeform meshes, smooth curves, and landmark-specific components out of scope. Related: #83 and #105.
repeated assemblies cannot follow an ellipse with local tangent orientation.
The narrow recommendation is EllipseRing + ellipse-only PathRepeat; generic CurvePath/spline/CAD semantics are explicitly rejected.
Production implementation is now tracked in #117, including stable schema/compiler integration, bounds/budgets/provenance, circular regression coverage, and MinePilot visual verification.
#110 can close as the completed research/evaluation task.
Activity
madawei2699 commentedon Sep 27, 2026
Research is complete in Draft PR #115.
The evidence supports a real generic representation gap:
The narrow recommendation is
EllipseRing+ ellipse-onlyPathRepeat; generic CurvePath/spline/CAD semantics are explicitly rejected.Production implementation is now tracked in #117, including stable schema/compiler integration, bounds/budgets/provenance, circular regression coverage, and MinePilot visual verification.
#110 can close as the completed research/evaluation task.