Skip to content

Plugin: American => British Translation of "pants" to "Trousers" is wrong when "pants" is a verb #16366

Closed
SubtitleEdit/plugins
#342

Description

@fraternl

American => British Translation of "pants" to "Trousers" is wrong when "pants" is a verb

Image

Activity

  1. changed the title [-]American => British Translation of "pants" to "Trousers" is wrong when "pants" is a verb[/-] [+]Plugin: American => British Translation of "pants" to "Trousers" is wrong when "pants" is a verb[/+] on Oct 23, 2026
  2. fraternl commented on Oct 24, 2026

    @fraternl
    Author

    I think the translation shouldn't happen at all.
    British use American words like "pants".
    The subtitle in English is used when its in English.

    It's a bit strange when they say "pants" and the subtitle is "trousers".

    If you remove it you don't have to fix it.

    Same for other words like

    Image
  3. accessallareas commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @accessallareas

    Honestly, I think deleting these kinds of words would open up problems for others. It's a good thing that the rules are strict and - as always with automatically search-replacing a lot of text - it requires checking afterwards. It depends very much on context if it is acceptable to have pants or movies or lifts in a British subtitle or not, so I would be glad to have this included in the list rather than excluded by default.

  4. fraternl commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @fraternl
    Author

    No-one is getting in to problems when "pants" does not get replaced by "trousers".
    The plugin is there for a British subtitle to replace American spelling with British spelling.
    If this is not done (word pairs are deleted) there is nothing wrong.

    The word "pants" is a word, although not originaly British, but any British will not see as an American word. (EDIT: it's British)
    But that's beside the point...

    If the word is used as a verb, "she pants" it has a complete and different meaning.
    You use "she pants" on both sides of the ocean and if you replace it with "she trousers" you get a ridiculous subtitle.

    The other 3 word pairs are used on both sides of the ocean and I don't think they belong there.
    But that's not that important.

    "she trousers heavily" gives a wrong subtitle.

  5. fraternl commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @fraternl
    Author

    This is what ChatGPT has to say.
    Interesting is that it makes it a "British English" word.
    So it shouldn't be "translated" at all.

    "Pants (verb) and pants (noun) are a homonym, more precisely a homograph.

    • To pants (verb): to breathe rapidly and heavily, usually because of exertion or heat. Example: The dog was panting.
    • Pants (noun): a garment covering the body from the waist to the ankles (British English).
      Interestingly, they are also pronounced differently:
    • Verb: pants /pænts/
    • Noun: pants /pænts/
      So they are homographs and homonyms, but not different-sounding words."
  6. niksedk commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @niksedk
    Member

    Thanks! Fixed in American to British v1.8.0 (SubtitleEdit/plugins#342), now available in the plugin list.

    "She pants heavily" is no longer changed. Some other words that also have a second meaning are no longer converted American to British either:

    • pants (verb)
    • tire/tires (verb: "I never tire of it")
    • draft/drafts (document, military or sports draft)
    • practice/practices and license (British noun/verb)
    • program/programs (computer program)
    • meter/meters (parking or gas meter)
    • install/installs

    British to American still converts these, since that direction is correct (trousers → pants, tyre → tire). Other pairs like movie → film are kept, as @accessallareas suggested, so please check the preview before applying.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions